Students Turn Ambition into Working Technology
Through the generosity of the Raisbeck Foundation, an endowed professorship helps Dr. Johann Dorfling empower Embry-Riddle students to turn ambitious ideas into working technology and develop the skills to succeed as professional engineers.
Dr. Johann Dorfling remembers a design review that did not go well.
The Embry-Riddle engineering students had failed to meet expectations. Rather than approve their work, Dorfling and his fellow mentor sent them back to try again.
“We basically failed them and said, ‘All right, we're going to redo this in a week,’” he recalls.
A year later, some of those students told him something he has never forgotten.
“‘That was really the best learning opportunity for us,’” Dorfling recalls them saying.
The experience affirmed his belief that engineering students need more than technical knowledge. They must learn to defend their decisions, recognize shortcomings and take responsibility for their work.
“It's important that we were teaching them actually through this process, and it's not just a checkpoint that's guaranteed you'll pass,” he says. “You actually have to make sure you do the work thoroughly.”
As the Raisbeck Distinguished Chair on Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University's Prescott Campus, Dorfling has the resources and flexibility to make such experiences central to his work.
Established through philanthropy by aviation entrepreneur James Raisbeck, the Raisbeck Engineering Design/Build/Test Endowed Chair was the university's first endowed faculty position. It was established to expand opportunities for students to learn engineering by designing, building and testing their ideas.
Dorfling takes that mission personally.
“That's really become just part of what I do every day,” he says. “How do I make sure students get this and how can I support?”
Students Bring the Ideas
Many projects Dorfling supports begin with students approaching him rather than the other way around.
“I find that if it's the students that want to initiate things and they have that ambition, then I want to be an enabler ... rather than try to make it very burdensome for them to try and get the money,” Dorfling says.
His test of their commitment is informal.
“I'll just tell students, you just need to annoy me enough. Because then they're showing me that they actually have buy-in to what they want to do.”
One group of seniors approached him about building a wire EDM machine, a computer-controlled system that uses electrical discharges to cut conductive materials. They wanted to install the completed machine in the campus makerspace but needed additional funding and assurance that the equipment would be accepted.
Dorfling agreed to both.
In another project, a student identified a shortage of publicly available propeller-performance data. Dorfling is working with students to develop a test stand for a wind tunnel, meeting regularly to review their progress.
The endowment also helps students attend engineering competitions when funding falls short. Sometimes his contribution covers the difference between sending 10 students and allowing more team members to participate.
“A lot of times I'm not the primary support,” he says. “I'm just giving them the extra that they need to get it done.”
The funding is flexible, but Dorfling measures each request against the donor's intentions.
“Am I doing something here that is supporting this vision of design-build-test on this campus?” he asks. “And if the answer is yes, then I can easily go ahead and support students in their project.”
“You are going to go and design things, build things, break things,” Dorfling says. “You're going to be doing some real engineering work.”
More Than Engineering
One of the clearest expressions of that philosophy is Embry-Riddle Prescott's Design-Build-Fly (DBF) team, which Dorfling co-mentors with Professor Smith.
The student-led organization designs, builds and flies an aircraft to meet the requirements of a national engineering competition.
“And it's fun to have a competition that you're competing in because it makes it real in some ways,” Dorfling says.
The club is organized to develop student leaders. Its president serves as project manager while the vice president acts as chief engineer. The chief engineer spends a year learning from the project manager before assuming that leadership role the following year.
Dorfling and his fellow mentor meet weekly with student leaders, helping them address technical problems, team conflicts and the demands of managing a complex project.
“Internal conflict comes up and challenges within the team comes up,” he says. “And we try to give them some advice on how to proceed and how to move things forward.”
Formal design reviews require students to explain technical decisions and defend their assumptions. Dorfling doesn't hesitate to criticize a weak presentation.
“If it's a bad presentation, we'll let them know and give them pointers on how to improve,” he says. “Those soft skills are really sometimes more important than the engineering skills. It doesn't matter that you've got good technical skills, if you can't communicate what you're doing to others.”
A pilot who owns a Cessna 210, Dorfling also brings firsthand flying experience to his mentorship.
“We're not just designing an aircraft on paper, we're designing it so that it would be able to fly,” he says.
That combination of technical knowledge and practical experience becomes especially valuable when students begin looking for jobs.
“The recruiters see DBF on their resumes, and then that's almost what the whole interview revolves around, is their experience in these hands-on projects, doing engineering, not just learning it along the way,” he says.
The Dinosaurs of DBF Wisdom
At Prescott, seniors are not permitted to hold leadership positions in the Design-Build-Fly club. Instead, freshmen, sophomores and juniors run the organization while seniors concentrate on their capstone projects.
The seniors and graduates have acquired an affectionate nickname.
“They're lovingly referred to as the dinosaurs of DBF wisdom,” Dorfling says.
Many remain active in the club, including graduates who have spent several years working in industry.
“We actually have a lot of the student alums that went through DBF, they'll join remotely to the design reviews,” he says. “So we have some students who are five years out working in industry, former students, and then they will join in.”
And they don't go easy on their successors.
“They'll dial in to join the meeting remotely and they spend a lot of time after the presentation tearing into the design and the assumptions and what they've done to really help guide them to improve their design.”
The club also emphasizes documentation so incoming student leaders can build on previous work rather than start from scratch.
Dorfling is working to expand hands-on opportunities through additional aircraft-design competitions, including those associated with the Vertical Flight Society and the Society of Automotive Engineers.
“You can only support so many students in one competition,” he explains. “When you go beyond 30, 40 students working on a single project, there's not enough work for everybody to do something meaningful.”
His goal is to create enough teams that more students can assume substantial engineering and leadership responsibilities.
Rivals Who Have Each Other's Backs
Dorfling takes satisfaction in how his students handle the pressures of competition.
“I found that our team has ... somehow they stand together really well at the competition and handle the stress of the competition when things don't go well,” he says.
He particularly enjoys the relationship between Embry-Riddle's Prescott and Daytona Beach Design-Build-Fly teams.
“The other thing that every year I love seeing is the Prescott and the Daytona Beach teams helping each other out,” he says. “They show up and we're competing against each other, but then there's a camaraderie as well that just exists.”
That cooperation extends to practical problems encountered during competition.
“If they need something, we're going to do what we can to support it. If we need something, they get it to us.”
Dorfling calls it “really fun to see that the students are competing against each other, but they do it in a very sportsman-like manner.”
A Promise to the Donor
For Dorfling, the endowed position has made student mentoring a consistent professional priority rather than an activity that must compete for time with other responsibilities.
“Now I can say, okay, this is my job. This is what I do.”
He attended a campus presentation by James Raisbeck early in his Embry-Riddle career but did not meet him personally. To better understand the gift, he sought out colleagues who participated in the original discussions.
“That's the one thing that's really stood out for me in this position, to stay as true as I can to the intent of the donor,” Dorfling says.
“Even though I didn't meet him and talk to him directly ... there are people here who were part of that conversation. So they were able to tell me some of the history behind it and give me insight.”
“That's been a really big part of it, to be able to just honor that gift.”
The mission also aligns closely with what he loves most about teaching.
“The gift is just so well aligned with what I like to do, and that is to work with students,” he says. “I like classroom teaching, but I really love the mentorship that we get outside of classes doing hands-on project.”
“Being in this position has really allowed me to pursue that and really try to grow that as much as I can, as much as I have capacity for it.”
For Dorfling, the opportunity carries a personal sense of gratitude.
“It's been really a big blessing to have this position.”